Some thoughts about the Ladies in snooker…

Reanne Evans, the dominant force in the ladie's game

First … I want to thank Matt for inviting me to post on his blog and offering the opportunity to share some of my views on a not so well known area of snooker, the Ladies’ game.

I’ve been following the ladies for a while now and I have been in three ranking events already this season. There is no denial that the level of the ladies’ game is way behind the men’s. Reanne Evans, 24, is the current WLBSA World Champion; she’s won it five times, she’s also the current IBSF World Champion. She’s undefeated for 49 matches in WLBSA ranking events, and counting. Her high break in competition is 140. That’s pretty impressive and yet she hasn’t been able to qualify for the main tour, despite taking part of the PIOS in the past. Also she will certainly lose her IBSF crown in the coming days because she hasn’t been able to travel to India to defend her title, by lack of a sponsor. So what’s wrong? Will we one day see a female amongst the game elite, or not?

“No, because girls are inferior …”

Yes, I’ve read that, literally, on forums. I’m hugely interested in neuroscience and I’m the first to accept that, on average, there are significant differences between “women’s brain” and “men’s brain”. While girls are usually better at verbal and social skills, boys have a better eye-hand coordination and spatial perception, both characteristics that would make them more apt to a game like snooker. They are also more competitive, again on average.

I wrote “on average”… because that does not mean anything when considering the individual. So you would expect that, given snooker does not require real physical strength, provided enough girls play the game, and proper coaching, at least some of them would be able to compete with the top boys. Today this isn’t the case. So why?

The answer is: because not many girls take on the game… although according to some coaches their number is increasing. There are several reasons for that situation to happen.

  • Only too often, clubs are not very welcoming to females, if they are allowed to play at all. Certainly in the UK, many clubs are “men only”. I must say that for a mainland Europe citizen this is shocking but there we go. Even Reanne confirmed to me that she’s not allowed to play in some clubs near her home, and that in clubs where she is accepted some men don’t want to play her because she’s a female. Hannah Jones (13 years old and currently ranked 12) and her father also complained about the patronizing attitude they were facing in clubs. Girls tend to be ridiculed or hassled. This is hard to take especially for teenagers. Another consequence of this is that girls find it hard to make progress because they are not allowed or encouraged to play against tougher male opposition. This is particularly problematic when they reach a good level as having challenges is essential to motivation and improvement.
  • Girls are not encouraged to play snooker. Rarely will you see a father introducing his daughter to the game and to the club. From a parent’s point of view this is understandable. Not only because of the unwelcoming cultural/societal context but mainly because there is not much hope for a girl to make a living out of snooker in the present state of the game. Prize money is so low that even the world champion can’t make a living of it. It wasn’t always that bad though. In the eighties and nineties there was a much stronger ladies field, not only in UK but worldwide, with the likes of Allison, Mandy and Kelly Fisher to name only a few. In the fall of 1997, just after the Grand Prix, the WLBSA joined the WPBSA. Snooker was still huge and the ladies had big expectations. It turned out that actually WPBSA did very little to support the ladies and when the tobacco ban entered into force they pleaded poverty and just dropped WLBSA penniless. That was early 2004 and since then the ladies game has been in a real slump. The most prominent UK players at the time fled to the US to make a living out of pool, very successfully, Allison Fisher being the prime example. The Asian players didn’t have the means anymore, or the interest to come and play in WLBSA events. It hasn’t changed unfortunately. I learned very recently that Hannah is making her debuts in 9-balls as well. There at least she has a professional future.
  • Girls are not shown and not sponsored. Both things go hand in hand of course, sponsors typically want exposure. The girls are never shown on television, very rarely on streaming. If you search for Allison Fisher on YouTube you will find plenty of pool and just one example of her playing snooker, a frame in a match of doubles with Steve Davis. Knowing that Allison is most probably the greatest ever lady in the game, that says it all … When WPBSA was in charge of the Ladies’ game the finals were played in Sheffield at the Crucible. All the necessary equipment was available to record at least some of the games. It could have been shown during the men’s matches mid session intervals, or during the various diversions BBC always offers during the World Championship. No, preference was always given to snippets about the male players … playing golf or fishing or whatever. The situation hasn’t improved. This year the World Championship will be played in Cambridge in a club where the ladies are very welcome. But it’s not an actual arena, so only a very limited audience, mainly friends and families will fit in the available space. And it’s not equipped even to allow for streaming. As a consequence, not only are the girls actually paying from their own money to compete but the whole WLBSA is largely relying on people, like Mandy Fisher, Tim Dunkley and Mark Jones who do it for the love of the game, on their spare time and at their own expense. And that’s also why the IBSF defending champion is not currently in India to defend her title.
  • Women find it hard to put the hours into practice. Obviously when you have to earn a living and you can’t live on your sport, you need another job. When kids come around, it’s mainly the women who take care of them, especially when they are young. This not only limits the time they can devote to practice, it also limits their freedom to travel around to venues. Simple facts of life but they add up to the other difficulties.

Having been to several ladies events over the last year, I’m convinced their snooker is every bit as interesting and enthralling as the men’s. Not so many big breaks but, partially because of that, a lot of twists and turns, drama and tension. Bringing the ladies in the media could attract a different type of audience and sponsors. After all it’s mainly the women doing the shopping. So it’s well worth to try and improve the situation. But how?

The floor is yours for comments and suggestions…

I want to thank Chris Turner, Mandy Fisher, Janie Watkins, Mark and Hannah Jones, Tim Dunkley, Marianne Williams, Dan Lewis, Simon Markham and Reanne Evans for taking the time to discuss this subject with me and providing me factual information that contributed to the “birth” of this article.

.

Thanks to Monique for such a well-researched article (Matt).

  • mscobina

    Great article, and astute observations. Im a female player from Melbourne, Australia. Trust me, the comparative lack of support and recognition for womens snooker means we have to work twice as hard to get half as far. I must have rocks in my head to spend the hours I do in solo practice. Finding a decent coach that won’t condescend you is a battle in itself. But hey, I love the game, and am way too stubborn to chuck it in. You have to be.

  • Black_cat from TSF

    Thank you, Monique, for this comprehensive piece. Shows the truth in ladies’ snooker and I can only hope for it to be seen by as many people as possible.

  • Tim Dunkley (World Snooker coach)

    True, true, true…however, speaking from a Chandler’s Ford Snooker Club point of view, things are changing.

    For about 12 years, Suzie Opacic, now ranked sixth on the WLBSA circuit, has ploughed a lone furrow in our neck of the woods.

    It’s ironic that although the withdrawal of tobacco sponsorship may have dealt women’s snooker a mortal blow, the smoking ban in clubs may have rekindled interest.

    We now have three young girls (Leah Gregory, Ellie Bull and Bethan Gibbs) who are all regulars in our Saturday morning under-13 league – and a couple of others who turn up occasionally when they can get out of bed in time.

  • Anna

    thanks Monique for this research and thanks Matt for providing space for the article. You may find a Russian translation here: http://top-snooker.com/news/articles/show/542 (just to your note) :)

  • http://aromatherapy4soul.com aromatherapy4soul

    Very sad to read this. Snooker is a fabulous game and young PEOPLE across the board should be encouraged to learn it and play it. To find such blatant and ongoing sexual discrimination in a Western World country in 2009 is also shocking and disturbing. Perhaps someone can come along and sort this sponsorship thing out. I can’t believe that a pie company can be the only option or that there is no sponsorship for the ladies, even without the exposure. Surely there are ladies in business who could be persuaded to pitch in.

    I have hope for the future …

  • http://www.hannahjones.co.uk Mark Jones

    Many thanks Monique for this insightful article, supported by lovely photographs, and thanks Matt for posting it :)

  • http://www.cuesport.tv Pete@Cuesport.tv

    Great post Monique. The womens game is an area that I still believe has huge potential to be developed. I think that the points about clubs being un-welcoming and women not being encouraged to play snooker I would say are quite true, but are changing.

    There would be no physical reason why women could not compete with men at a high level, there are many women now that are getting great results in pool when competing with men on an even keel.

    In my opinion it comes from a lack of top level players to compete against in the current climate and the women involved in the game not wanting to risk the large entry fee’s to compete in predominantly mens tournaments.

    I don’t have an answer but believe that the womens game needs as much support as possible so that it does not fade away.

  • http://snookersceney.blogspot.com/ Sammy@SnookerSceney

    Been following Hannah for a while, interseting article and would love Evans on the tour

  • Elin

    As a female guitarist and in a male dominated work field, I can totally relate to the problems described in this post. Why are men so terrified of female competition? Calm down, is all I’m saying, and start treating women equally.

  • http://www.6redworldchampionships.com 6 Red

    It will be very interesting to see how Reanne fairs out in the 6 Red Event in Ireland. She will be the only female player but with only 6 Red’s I dont see why she cant go toe to toe with the Top Pro’s.

  • mscobina

    Elin!

    I too played in bands for many years (even had two record deals), and there are big similarities – namely that your peers don’t usually take you seriously, and you are often supported/promoted as a novelty rather than a developing player like all the rest.

    However, the amount of times i’ve been unselfconsciously told that i’m “not bad for a girl” in snooker vastly outnumner the times i’ve been told that in musical contexts. I think that the snooker community is comprised of more ‘old-school’ blokes than rock and roll, which is largely a young persons game with pretentions to PC appropriateness.

    Added to that, my dad was WAY more concerned by my interest in cue sports than he was my interest in guitars. He once found me practicing on a 20c table in my school uniform and promptly grounded me. The ‘family’ billard table was inherited by my male cousins who can barely swing a cue – despite the fact that my family all know that i’m a mad keen player.

    Just a couple of examples of the barriers to participation that female players face.

    Basically, we put in the same effort for less prospect of prize money – or prestige.

    Can you blame the majority of women for chucking it in before they have fully developed their potential?

  • Johnny Peetermans

    Every word so true …. i’ve been coaching some female amateur players in Belgium now for a couple of years and find it very interesting to see how they evolve in the game. Every single lady i coach is full of ambition, wants to learn and puts a lot of work and means into her game … but still they’re considered as less good players ….
    I will continue to coach female players because they deserve the attention !!!
    A few weeks ago i got to know the wonderful lady that wrote the article above, she and some more people deserve a “ladies snookerworld”, it’s a tough game they play, full of tactics and more …. Sometimes i get so tired of male pro’s banging in those high breaks as if the pockets where twice the size they were 15 years ago … I miss the tactical battles, the defensive exchanges ……
    All that, i find in the ladies game, and believe me … they also knock in breaks

    Ladies, keep playing !!!

    Johnny Peetermans

  • http://starfields.ws StarFields

    On the http://www.worldladiessnooker.co.uk website there are no contact details for the WLBSA and the contact form doesn’t work. Any suggestions who they might be and how they can be contacted?

  • http://www.hannahjones.co.uk Mark Jones

    Hi Starfields, yes that is my domain, I shall sort it our for you today. Apologies….

    If you want to contact the chairman Mandy Fisher in the meantime you can send an email to worldladiesnooker@ntlworld.com

    Cheers.